Headline tester and analyzerWho wins
the click?
Compare 2 to 8 headlines, blog titles or email subject lines side by side. Each is scored on five stats, docked for clickbait, and ranked by power rating.
How the belt is won
Every headline gets a power rating out of 100. The ring is empty for now. Paste your own contenders or load a sample bout.
- 60
Five judged stats
Curiosity, clarity, specificity, emotional pull and credibility, each scored on a five step scale.
- 25
Would they click
The chance a reader in your audience clicks or opens it in that format.
- 15
Delivers a want
Whether it promises something your audience actually wants.
- -30
Clickbait penalty
Up to 30 points off once the clickbait chance passes 50%.
How headlines are compared
Headline Arena lets you compare 2 to 8 headlines at once instead of scoring one in isolation. Jev scores each one for the division and audience you pick, then the field is ranked by power rating out of 100. Every number comes from Jev answering typed questions. Every sentence on the results is a template filled with those numbers.
The five stats
Curiosity
How much does this headline make the audience want to find out more?
Scored from "gives no reason to read on" to "the reader has to know the answer". Worth 22% of the stat score.
Clarity
How quickly and easily can the audience understand what this is about?
Scored from "confusing, the topic is unclear" to "instantly clear, nothing to decode". Worth 20% of the stat score.
Specificity
How concrete is the headline: numbers, names, outcomes, timeframes, details?
Scored from "completely vague and generic" to "precise and vivid, could only be about this one thing". Worth 18% of the stat score.
Emotional pull
How strongly does the headline make the audience feel something (hope, fear, delight, outrage, recognition)?
Scored from "flat, no feeling at all" to "a strong gut reaction". Worth 18% of the stat score.
Credibility
How believable and trustworthy does this headline seem to the audience?
Scored from "sounds like a scam or obvious exaggeration" to "sounds authoritative and trustworthy". Worth 22% of the stat score.
The power rating
- 60 points come from the five stats above.
- 25 points come from the chance a reader in your audience clicks or opens it in that format.
- 15 points come from whether it promises something that audience actually wants.
- Up to 30 points off once the chance it is clickbait passes 50%. Clickbait here means it relies on hype, shouting, fake shock, or deliberately hiding the point to trick the reader into clicking. The check is meant to pass a headline that states or hints at its real topic honestly, even if it is bold, punchy, or promises a benefit.
Ratings sort into tiers: Title contender at 80 and up, Main card at 65 and up, Undercard at 50 and up, Journeyman at 35 and up, Needs a new camp below that.
Head to head
Pick any two headlines and they go five rounds, one per stat. A round is a draw when the two are less than 3 points apart. The decision follows the power rating: a gap of 15 or more is a knockout, 6 or more a unanimous decision, and anything closer a split decision. When the ratings tie, the higher click chance wins.
Divisions
- Blog titles. Judged as a blog post title shown in search results and social feeds. Lines over 70 characters are marked as long.
- Email subjects. Judged as an email subject line shown in a crowded inbox. Lines over 50 characters are marked as long.
- Tweet hooks. Judged as the opening line of a tweet or thread shown in a scrolling timeline. Lines over 120 characters are marked as long.
- YouTube titles. Judged as a YouTube video title shown under a thumbnail in recommendations. Lines over 60 characters are marked as long.